Jason Scotland

Ok, Here's a poll that should get some talking points going.

Having watched Jason Scotland since his arrival at the club, personally I think he is nothing special and i'm not a JS fan, so with nothing else to do i thought i'd post this Poll to see how others felt on STID.

A truthful, honest oppinion would be appreciated.

The poll will run till the end of the year.

completely useless, can't wait till he doesn't score against us.

Cornellyjak wrote:Ok, Here's a poll that should get some talking points going.

Having watched Jason Scotland since his arrival at the club, personally I think he is nothing special and i'm not a JS fan, so with nothing else to do i thought i'd post this Poll to see how others felt on STID.

A truthful, honest oppinion would be appreciated.

The poll will run till the end of the year.

it shows aswell that u ain't a JS fan....there's only one positive and four negative choices....somewhere inbetween for me maybe

How about 'Quality, when he has a decent partner'?

JACK77 wrote:

Cornellyjak wrote:Ok, Here's a poll that should get some talking points going.

Having watched Jason Scotland since his arrival at the club, personally I think he is nothing special and i'm not a JS fan, so with nothing else to do i thought i'd post this Poll to see how others felt on STID.

A truthful, honest oppinion would be appreciated.

The poll will run till the end of the year.

it shows aswell that u ain't a JS fan....there's only one positive and four negative choices....somewhere inbetween for me maybe

Im not voting in this as im running it and my poll would be seen as biased.
Dont need to vote , I think you can all see how i feel.

DBSwansea wrote:How about 'Quality, when he has a decent partner'?

He has no first touch, has no control and even if he was playing in an opponents half and all the defenders stood off him he would still blunder his touches.

If he had a pertner he'd make them look bad.

Cornellyjak wrote:

JACK77 wrote:

Cornellyjak wrote:Ok, Here's a poll that should get some talking points going.

Having watched Jason Scotland since his arrival at the club, personally I think he is nothing special and i'm not a JS fan, so with nothing else to do i thought i'd post this Poll to see how others felt on STID.

A truthful, honest oppinion would be appreciated.

The poll will run till the end of the year.

it shows aswell that u ain't a JS fan....there's only one positive and four negative choices....somewhere inbetween for me maybe

Im not voting in this as im running it and my poll would be seen as biased.
Dont need to vote , I think you can all see how i feel.

Mark , give me an in between to put in then..

most of his goals last year came when he had a strike partner. You're not a Trundle mark are you? He'd be useless in our system.

well...he played a major part in gettin us into the Championship so i really can't knock him to be honest. I wouldnt say he was pure class mind...and lets face it his ball controll is the other end of the scale compaired to Trunds....but maybe like db said, a quality partner required

DBSwansea wrote:most of his goals last year came when he had a strike partner. You're not a Trundle mark are you? He'd be useless in our system.

yep

JACK77 wrote:

DBSwansea wrote:most of his goals last year came when he had a strike partner. You're not a Trundle mark are you? He'd be useless in our system.

yep

DB, Trunds would be knocking them in for fun with this midfield.

Cornellyjak wrote:

JACK77 wrote:

DBSwansea wrote:most of his goals last year came when he had a strike partner. You're not a Trundle mark are you? He'd be useless in our system.

yep

DB, Trunds would be knocking them in for fun with this midfield.

As much as i'd like to see that, I doub't he would. a 4-5-1 system requires the striker to link with the wingers, play with thier back to goal and actually put in a decent work rate.

Towards the end of his time here, he was lazy and selfish but he got away with it because he was a fans favorite. People make a big fuss of the the way he's been played at Bristol but the truth is after paying a million for him, if he was good enough he'd be playing and scoring regularly.

For me of all of our strikers of the past few years, the one that stands out as a foil for Scotland is Bayo. When he ran with the ball he took the entire defence with him.

Of our current players, I thought that Pintado would be our best choice but he hasn't been good enough since his back injury. Bauza puts a solid shift in but isn't a predator, and Brandy needs to play his football lower down the league system for a while.

Scotland for me, is wasted in this system. But, he's experienced enough in it for it to work and it's the work he's put in to some of our games that allows our midfield to get amongst the goals. Although I do think he's been poor recently. Unfortunatley our other options aren't as good.

DBSwansea wrote:

Cornellyjak wrote:

JACK77 wrote:

DBSwansea wrote:most of his goals last year came when he had a strike partner. You're not a Trundle mark are you? He'd be useless in our system.

yep

DB, Trunds would be knocking them in for fun with this midfield.

As much as i'd like to see that, I doub't he would. a 4-5-1 system requires the striker to link with the wingers, play with thier back to goal and actually put in a decent work rate.

Towards the end of his time here, he was lazy and selfish but he got away with it because he was a fans favorite. People make a big fuss of the the way he's been played at Bristol but the truth is after paying a million for him, if he was good enough he'd be playing and scoring regularly.

For me of all of our strikers of the past few years, the one that stands out as a foil for Scotland is Bayo. When he ran with the ball he took the entire defence with him.

Of our current players, I thought that Pintado would be our best choice but he hasn't been good enough since his back injury. Bauza puts a solid shift in but isn't a predator, and Brandy needs to play his football lower down the league system for a while.

Scotland for me, is wasted in this system. But, he's experienced enough in it for it to work and it's the work he's put in to some of our games that allows our midfield to get amongst the goals. Although I do think he's been poor recently. Unfortunatley our other options aren't as good.

Lots of truth in that Dave, but, still not good enough

But he's the best we've got.

Pure class

if it wasnt for him we wudnt be in this league so stop slaggin him off cause he aint scored as much this season, some fans are hard to plz

i love this bloke and hes are best striker are best goalscroing striker, so rather than slag him off get behind him once he scores he will carry on hes just got injurys at vital parts and been droped as well for some reason, i woukd start with him every single time

Cornellyjak wrote:

Cornellyjak wrote:

JACK77 wrote:

Cornellyjak wrote:Ok, Here's a poll that should get some talking points going.

Having watched Jason Scotland since his arrival at the club, personally I think he is nothing special and i'm not a JS fan, so with nothing else to do i thought i'd post this Poll to see how others felt on STID.

A truthful, honest oppinion would be appreciated.

The poll will run till the end of the year.

it shows aswell that u ain't a JS fan....there's only one positive and four negative choices....somewhere inbetween for me maybe

Im not voting in this as im running it and my poll would be seen as biased.
Dont need to vote , I think you can all see how i feel.

Mark , give me an in between to put in then..

i'm tryin to fink m8t..lol... "average in the Championship" or umm...."Good,but not that good" or... "can play well with the right support"...

JACK77 wrote:

Cornellyjak wrote:

Cornellyjak wrote:

JACK77 wrote:

Cornellyjak wrote:Ok, Here's a poll that should get some talking points going.

Having watched Jason Scotland since his arrival at the club, personally I think he is nothing special and i'm not a JS fan, so with nothing else to do i thought i'd post this Poll to see how others felt on STID.

A truthful, honest oppinion would be appreciated.

The poll will run till the end of the year.

it shows aswell that u ain't a JS fan....there's only one positive and four negative choices....somewhere inbetween for me maybe

Im not voting in this as im running it and my poll would be seen as biased.
Dont need to vote , I think you can all see how i feel.

Mark , give me an in between to put in then..

i'm tryin to fink m8t..lol... "average in the Championship" or umm...."Good,but not that good" or... "can play well with the right support"...

hes quality just get behind him its not hard

I think Scotland is a good player. If the fans stopped getting on his back maybe he would preform better.
Tbh i only think that his control and first touch need some brushing up but thats it. Without Jason Scotland we wouldn't be in this league and he is still scoring goals
He has scored more goals than Pintado but Pintado doesnt get any stick from the fans.

MrSafe wrote:I think Scotland is a good player. If the fans stopped getting on his back maybe he would preform better.
Tbh i only think that his control and first touch need some brushing up but thats it. Without Jason Scotland we wouldn't be in this league and he is still scoring goals
He has scored more goals than Pintado but Pintado doesnt get any stick from the fans.

correct exactly what i said a few comments back im glad someone is on the same wave length as me

Not everyone was running him down

MrSafe wrote:I think Scotland is a good player. If the fans stopped getting on his back maybe he would preform better.
Tbh i only think that his control and first touch need some brushing up but thats it. Without Jason Scotland we wouldn't be in this league and he is still scoring goals
He has scored more goals than Pintado but Pintado doesnt get any stick from the fans.

Yeh but in this league he ain't pure class....yet anyway

Jack4life wrote:

MrSafe wrote:I think Scotland is a good player. If the fans stopped getting on his back maybe he would preform better.
Tbh i only think that his control and first touch need some brushing up but thats it. Without Jason Scotland we wouldn't be in this league and he is still scoring goals
He has scored more goals than Pintado but Pintado doesnt get any stick from the fans.

correct exactly what i said a few comments back im glad someone is on the same wave length as me

Yea its cos we are cool lol

JACK77 wrote:

MrSafe wrote:I think Scotland is a good player. If the fans stopped getting on his back maybe he would preform better.
Tbh i only think that his control and first touch need some brushing up but thats it. Without Jason Scotland we wouldn't be in this league and he is still scoring goals
He has scored more goals than Pintado but Pintado doesnt get any stick from the fans.

Yeh but in this league he ain't pure class....yet anyway

Ok in this league he aint the best goalscorer as we know but he is still our top goalscoring striker this season

MrSafe wrote:

JACK77 wrote:

MrSafe wrote:I think Scotland is a good player. If the fans stopped getting on his back maybe he would preform better.
Tbh i only think that his control and first touch need some brushing up but thats it. Without Jason Scotland we wouldn't be in this league and he is still scoring goals
He has scored more goals than Pintado but Pintado doesnt get any stick from the fans.

Yeh but in this league he ain't pure class....yet anyway

Ok in this league he aint the best goalscorer as we know but he is still our top goalscoring striker this season

and its thanks to him we are in this league

i think that jason was the best goal scorer last year. He played a vital part in getting us promtid, but he could laern how to control the ball now an
then